Episode 131 - The Politics and Price of Free Speech in American Schools - 16:1 - An Education Podcast Episode 131 - The Politics and Price of Free Speech in American Schools - 16:1 - An Education Podcast
African American woman using a megaphone to protest, symbolizing activism and empowerment.

Episode 131 - The Politics and Price of Free Speech in American Schools

April 17, 2025

Education News

We offer episode transcripts upon request. Please use our contact form to request an episode transcript.

Higher education in the U.S. faces an unprecedented storm of political and financial upheaval, highlighting critical tensions around free speech, academic freedom, and institutional integrity. Columbia University’s initial compliance with demands from the Trump administration—banning protest masks, revising protest policies, and ceding departmental autonomy—signals a troubling shift away from protecting academic freedom, but capitulation isn’t the end of the story. Harvard University is resisting similar pressures, fiercely defending the right to independent scholarship against federal overreach under Title VI. Universities like Cornell, Northwestern, Johns Hopkins, and the University of Pennsylvania are grappling with massive financial disruptions impacting critical research and community programs.

In K-12 education, similar tensions emerge: the past few weeks have brought DHS/ICE interventions in LA schools alongside Maine’s successful pushback against federal interference in childhood nutrition programs. Even internationally, students at Netzaberg Middle School in Germany experienced what they perceived as administrative retaliation for peaceful protest, underscoring global stakes in educational autonomy.

In lighter news, this week we are also catching up on Ohio’s pending legislation around school cell phone use and the unresolved struggle over digital boundaries and mental health. Jonathan Haidt’s recent conversations on The Ezra Klein Show highlight the ongoing challenge of balancing protective measures without regressing into outdated moral frameworks. For all of this and more, check out the latest episode. Thanks for listening.

For a full list of episode sources and resources, visit our website at sixteentoone.com/archives.

Sources & Resources:

Columbia’s Former Leader Faced Contentious Interview After Resigning – The New York Times

‘Our Kids Are the Least Flourishing Generation We Know Of’ – The New York Times

Proposed Ohio bill would ban student use of cellphones during school | 10tv.com

Homeland Security Tries to Enter LAUSD Schools – LAist

Federal judge orders Trump administration to unfreeze funding to Maine | AP News

Parents at DODEA school say student walkout was stopped by snap lockdown drill | Stars and Stripes

Johns Hopkins University Slashes 2000 Jobs after Trump Administration Grant Cut – Reuters

US cancels $400 million in grants, contracts to Columbia University over antisemitism allegations | Reuters

Columbia Agrees to Trump’s Demands After Federal Funds Are Stripped – The New York Times

Columbia’s Katrina Armstrong Resigns Amid Trump’s Attacks

Columbia – Message From Dr. Katrina Armstrong

Columbia Agrees to Trump’s Demands

1 Advancing Our Work to Combat Discrimination, Harassment, and Antisemitism at Columbia Columbia University has, throughout its

Harvard professors sue Trump administration over funding cut threats | WBUR News

Harvard University faculty sue to block Trump review of nearly $9bn in funding

Universities push back against Trump’s cuts on federal funding : NPR

Trump administration freezes $1.8 billion for Cornell and Northwestern

Trump suspends $175 million in funding to University of Pennsylvania over trans athletes : NPR

Johns Hopkins University slashes 2,000 jobs after Trump administration grant cut | Reuters

Our bond at a moment of challenge | Speeches and Writings | Office of the President

Federal judge orders Trump administration to unfreeze funding to Maine | AP News

Homeland Security agents attempted to enter 2 LAUSD schools. Here’s what families should know | LAist

Feds say agents went to Los Angeles schools to do welfare check on migrant children

Proposed Ohio bill would ban student use of cellphones during school | 10tv.com

Crowds flock to newest Catholic saint in Assisi — a millennial teen whose ordinariness is the draw

Who was Carlo Acutis, the Catholic Church’s new millennial saint | AP News

Players who have won the career Grand Slam in men’s golf – NBC Sports

The Promise of American Higher Education – Harvard University President

Sustaining Columbia’s Vital Mission | Office of the President

The early 2000s capacitor plague is probably not just a stolen recipe – Ars Technica

16:1 Educator Newsletter

16:1 is launching an email newsletter! Join our mailing list for news and updates designed by educators, for educators!

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

We use Brevo as our marketing platform. By submitting this form, you acknowledge that the information you provided will be transferred to Brevo for processing in accordance with their terms of use. You may unsubscribe at any time using the link in our newsletter.

News & Event Announcements
Stay informed on the latest education headlines and learn about upcoming events hosted by 16:1 podcast and Moonbeam Multimedia.
Job Postings & Resources
Sign up for educator resources, job postings from partner organizations, and more!

Contact 16:1

Have a question? Suggestion for an upcoming show? Want to partner with 16:1? We’d love to hear from you. Please contact us using the form below.